Old Town Mexican Cafe | 2489 San Diego Ave. | San Diego, CA
In the street-front window of the Old Town Mexican Cafe, women are making fresh tortillas. Based on this alone, I thought this place would definitely be a five-sombrero joint. As I entered in to the restaurant, the stench of lard was in the air (not a good sign). The place was packed and I was willing to forego the smell in my quest for the perfect plate of nachos.
When my nachos arrived, I instantly knew they were going to be sub-par. The bowl of sour cream and guac on top of the dish was one indication and the glob of cheese that practically swallowed the plate was another. The nachos had absolutely no flavor and were practically inedible.
Don’t believe the hype surrounding this award-winning joint.
![]()








